September 25, 2026 · We got it wrong
- What it said
- Pages about Guarneiri et al. 2024 said it appeared in Nutrition Reviews and that digestion is about 3% of daily energy expenditure. They presented the review's 72 kcal a day, one trial's difference in total daily energy expenditure (about 3%), as the extra calories it takes to digest a high-protein meal or as 'protein's thermic advantage', sometimes 'at typical intakes', 'the energy cost of a 30-minute walk' or a '72-120 kcal' range. They said the advantage 'disappears', 'vanishes' or is 'gone' during a calorie deficit or on longer diets, where the paper found it was not statistically significant, and in other places said a meal's extra heat was still produced on long-term diets, which the paper did not find. They called it 'the largest meta-analysis ever conducted' and protein's effect 'the largest of any food'. They credited the commonly cited 20-30% digestion cost, and our calorie arithmetic built on it, to the 52 studies, and said the effect held or was robust 'across study designs and populations'. Three citations carried invented titles and one an invented co-author, a claim page quoted the paper with sentences that are not in it, the study page called the first author's firm independent, and it credited another study's insulin finding to this paper.
- What it says now
- The journal is Advances in Nutrition and digestion's share is about 10%, as the paper says. The 72 kcal is described as what it is: in one trial the review uses as an example, a higher-protein diet raised total daily burn by 72 calories (about 3%), and on longer diets the review credits such rises mainly to resting metabolism, not digestion. Results that were not statistically significant are called that, with their numbers (for example, 4 calorie-deficit comparisons, P = 0.407). The paper is a 2024 meta-analysis of 52 studies, which its authors describe as the first to cover both single meals and longer-term diets. The 20-30% range is labelled as the commonly cited figure and our arithmetic as ours. Citations carry the paper's real title and its six authors, the claim quotes the paper's own conclusion, and the study page says the first author's firm reports funding or consulting fees from General Mills and other food companies.
- Why
- The paper cited was always the right one; the descriptions around it were written from our notes and earlier drafts instead of being checked line by line against the paper. A scan while fuelling a new Short on whole-food digestion found the wrong journal, the 3% and the 72-calorie misreading on 5 pages; reading the full paper for the fix found the rest. Four pages' audio repeated some of these statements; it was regenerated with the fix.
- Corrected
- Short Does the Thermic Effect of Food Matter for Weight Loss?
- Short Spicy Food Does Boost Metabolism. Here’s the Exact Number.
- Claim Does Protein Burn More Calories in Digestion Than Carbs and Fat?
- Guide Calories and Metabolism: Your Engine Is Fine, Your Gauge Is Broken
- Study How Many Calories Does Your Body Burn Digesting Protein?
- Built on it
8 shorts · 4 recipes · 9 recipe hubs
- The paper
- Guarneiri LL, Adams CG, Garcia-Jackson B, Koecher K, Wilcox ML, Maki KC (2024). Effects of Varying Protein Amounts and Types on Diet-Induced Thermogenesis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Advances in Nutrition 15(12):100332Read the paper
- Found by
- Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.