FitChef

The log: one day.

September 25, 2026

6 corrections on 9 pages. Most arrive together: one paper read again against every page that cites it, and every page fixed the same day.

A 2024 meta-analysis of protein and the calories burned in digestion was misdescribed on 5 pages: wrong journal, a one-trial daily figure presented as the cost of digesting protein, results called 'gone' that were only not significant, invented titles and a quote the paper never wrote

September 25, 2026 · We got it wrong

What it said
Pages about Guarneiri et al. 2024 said it appeared in Nutrition Reviews and that digestion is about 3% of daily energy expenditure. They presented the review's 72 kcal a day, one trial's difference in total daily energy expenditure (about 3%), as the extra calories it takes to digest a high-protein meal or as 'protein's thermic advantage', sometimes 'at typical intakes', 'the energy cost of a 30-minute walk' or a '72-120 kcal' range. They said the advantage 'disappears', 'vanishes' or is 'gone' during a calorie deficit or on longer diets, where the paper found it was not statistically significant, and in other places said a meal's extra heat was still produced on long-term diets, which the paper did not find. They called it 'the largest meta-analysis ever conducted' and protein's effect 'the largest of any food'. They credited the commonly cited 20-30% digestion cost, and our calorie arithmetic built on it, to the 52 studies, and said the effect held or was robust 'across study designs and populations'. Three citations carried invented titles and one an invented co-author, a claim page quoted the paper with sentences that are not in it, the study page called the first author's firm independent, and it credited another study's insulin finding to this paper.
What it says now
The journal is Advances in Nutrition and digestion's share is about 10%, as the paper says. The 72 kcal is described as what it is: in one trial the review uses as an example, a higher-protein diet raised total daily burn by 72 calories (about 3%), and on longer diets the review credits such rises mainly to resting metabolism, not digestion. Results that were not statistically significant are called that, with their numbers (for example, 4 calorie-deficit comparisons, P = 0.407). The paper is a 2024 meta-analysis of 52 studies, which its authors describe as the first to cover both single meals and longer-term diets. The 20-30% range is labelled as the commonly cited figure and our arithmetic as ours. Citations carry the paper's real title and its six authors, the claim quotes the paper's own conclusion, and the study page says the first author's firm reports funding or consulting fees from General Mills and other food companies.
Why
The paper cited was always the right one; the descriptions around it were written from our notes and earlier drafts instead of being checked line by line against the paper. A scan while fuelling a new Short on whole-food digestion found the wrong journal, the 3% and the 72-calorie misreading on 5 pages; reading the full paper for the fix found the rest. Four pages' audio repeated some of these statements; it was regenerated with the fix.
Built on it

8 shorts · 4 recipes · 9 recipe hubs

The paper
Guarneiri LL, Adams CG, Garcia-Jackson B, Koecher K, Wilcox ML, Maki KC (2024). Effects of Varying Protein Amounts and Types on Diet-Induced Thermogenesis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Advances in Nutrition 15(12):100332Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.
Li et al. 2017 2 corrections · 3 pages

September 25, 2026 · We got it wrong

Frozen vegetables: our pages made the fridge comparison more one-sided than the studies found

What it said
The study page and its audio said five days in the fridge cost fresh green beans 40% of their vitamin C while the frozen bag 'hadn't shifted'. The claim said the broccoli in the fridge 'was losing' its nutrients, that fridge-stored corn 'lost over half its beta-carotene', that frozen produce gave the same nutrient levels whatever the season or store, and that vitamin C was perfectly consistent across both studies. The Short's audio said spinach loses 75% of its vitamin C by Wednesday, three days after it is bought.
What it says now
The 40% is the gap between fridge-stored and frozen green beans: frozen beans had more vitamin C even than fresh beans bought the same day, and five days in the fridge cost 13%, a drop that was not statistically significant. The pages now say that most comparisons showed no significant difference, that frozen came out ahead more often than the reverse, and that fridge-stored broccoli kept more beta-carotene and folate than frozen, and fridge-stored spinach more vitamin C. The Short's audio gives the 75% as the loss over a week.
Why
Li et al. (2017), Tables 1 to 3: green beans had 7.7, 6.7 and 11.0 mg of vitamin C per 100 g fresh, fridge-stored and frozen; fridge-stored broccoli had 1,710 µg of beta-carotene per 100 g against 940 frozen; spinach had less vitamin C frozen than fresh or fridge-stored. The study pooled produce from six supermarkets and reports no season-by-season or store-by-store comparison. The 75% spinach figure is a seven-day loss at 4 °C (Favell, 1998, as reported by Rickman et al., 2007). Our pages turned comparisons into losses and left out the results that went the other way.
Built on it

1 guide · 8 shorts

The paper
Li L, Pegg RB, Eitenmiller RR, Chun J-Y, Kerrihard AL. Selected nutrient analyses of fresh, fresh-stored, and frozen fruits and vegetables. J Food Compos Anal 2017;59:8-17.Read the paper
Found by
Our own checks of the site.

September 25, 2026 · We got it wrong

Frozen vegetables: a study paid for by the Frozen Food Foundation was called independent

What it said
The study page called the University of Georgia team behind Li et al. (2017) 'an independent team' and its result 'independent confirmation', its audio said the research came from 'independent teams', and it said the UC Davis papers stand on 'independent academic funding'. The claim described 'two independent laboratory analyses' and 'two independent university laboratories'.
What it says now
Both pages now say 'two separate' teams or analyses and state that the Georgia study was funded by the Frozen Food Foundation, which also chose the fruits and vegetables it tested. The study page now says the UC Davis papers name no funder and declare no competing financial interest, and that their seeds were donated by Seminis Vegetable Seed Co.
Why
Li et al. (2017) state: 'This work was supported by a grant from the Frozen Food Foundation', and that the choice of produce 'was predetermined by the Frozen Food Foundation (FFF), the funding agency for this study'. Both pages disclosed that funding elsewhere, but 'independent' beside an industry-funded study tells a reader the opposite, and our rule is that industry-funded research is never called independent. The two Bouzari et al. (2015) papers name no funder at all, so 'independent academic funding' was a claim they do not make.
Built on it

1 guide · 9 shorts

The paper
Li L, Pegg RB, Eitenmiller RR, Chun J-Y, Kerrihard AL. Selected nutrient analyses of fresh, fresh-stored, and frozen fruits and vegetables. J Food Compos Anal 2017;59:8-17.Read the paper
Found by
Our own checks of the site.
Bouzari et al. 2015 2 corrections · 3 pages

September 25, 2026 · We got it wrong

Frozen vegetables: more of our lines understated what freezing and blanching cost

What it said
The Short's summary and answer said there were 'two exceptions' (beta-carotene and myrosinase), credited both to a review that covers neither, and said everything that survives blanching holds in the freezer. The study page said the carrots' fiber loss was not caused by frozen storage, named iron as the only mineral that dropped, gave leaching as the cause of the iron drop, and said the UC Davis team thinks the heat 'cracked open cell walls'. The claim called beta-carotene 'the single clear exception', said blanching causes 'minor' iron leaching and that nutrients are 'locked in at processing', and said vitamin E, calcium and copper show no loss during frozen storage.
What it says now
All three pages now name the exceptions the papers report: beta-carotene fell by more than half over 90 days in frozen peas, spinach and carrots; frozen spinach and one of two carrot varieties had 10 to 45% less iron than fresh; frozen peas, spinach and corn had about 7 to 18% less magnesium; and both carrot varieties lost about a quarter of their fiber in frozen storage. The iron drop is placed at the blanching step, with the authors' two possible causes, iron leaching out or soil washing off. The rise in vitamin E is described as the authors describe it, as a possible effect of steam blanching. Summaries now say 'most nutrients' and 'the biggest exception', and the Short's summary box credits each source it draws on.
Why
Checked line by line against the two companion papers by Bouzari, Holstege and Barrett (2015) and, for myrosinase, Dosz and Jeffery (2013). It is the same mistake as our correction of the Short's minerals FAQ earlier on 25 September 2026 (2026-09-25-frozen-vegetables-some-minerals-and-fiber-did): lines written from the abstract turned 'most showed no difference' into 'nothing changed'. That correction fixed only the sentence it was found in. When it went live, we checked every page citing these papers against the papers themselves, and found these lines. The study also shows vitamin E slipping during frozen storage in broccoli and carrots, and it measured calcium and copper only right after processing, so 'no loss during frozen storage' was more than it showed.
Built on it

1 guide · 8 shorts

The paper
Bouzari A, Holstege D, Barrett DM. Mineral, Fiber, and Total Phenolic Retention in Eight Fruits and Vegetables: A Comparison of Refrigerated and Frozen Storage. J Agric Food Chem 2015;63:951-956.Read the paper
Found by
Our own checks of the site.

September 25, 2026 · We got it wrong

Frozen vegetables: some minerals and fiber did drop, which our FAQ said they did not

What it said
The FAQ 'Do frozen vegetables lose minerals and fiber?' ended: 'Minerals and fiber hold steady either way.'
What it says now
It now names the drops its source reports: frozen spinach and one carrot variety had 10 to 45% less iron than fresh, frozen peas, spinach and corn about 7 to 18% less magnesium, and both carrot varieties lost about a quarter of their fiber in frozen storage.
Why
The FAQ's source, Bouzari, Holstege and Barrett (2015), found no significant fresh-versus-frozen difference for most of the eight fruits and vegetables it tested, and that part of our answer was right. The same paper reports these exceptions: 'in spinach and carrot variety A, the frozen samples had between 10% and 45% less iron than the fresh samples'; 'Frozen peas, spinach, and corn contained between ~7% and 18% less magnesium'; 'Both varieties of carrots lost fiber (~25%) during frozen storage'. Our answer turned 'most showed no difference' into 'hold steady either way'. It was written from the paper's abstract, which says results depended on the commodity but does not list the exceptions, and our checks did not test the sentence against the full paper. The error was found when a new Short on raw versus cooked spinach, which reports the same paper's spinach result, was checked against the rest of the site.
The paper
Bouzari A, Holstege D, Barrett DM. Mineral, Fiber, and Total Phenolic Retention in Eight Fruits and Vegetables: A Comparison of Refrigerated and Frozen Storage. J Agric Food Chem 2015;63:951-956.Read the paper
Found by
Our own checks of the site.
A 2010 digestion study was described as comparing matched meals; its whole-food meal had more protein and about three times the fibre

September 25, 2026 · We got it wrong

What it said
The page said that whole-food meals needed nearly twice the digestive energy of processed-food meals 'made with the same macronutrients' (narrative) and 'made from the same ingredients' (Weight of Evidence card). The card added that food form may be the bigger factor in how much nutrition the body extracts.
What it says now
Both places now say that a whole-food sandwich meal cost nearly twice the digestive energy of a processed one with the same calories, and that the whole-food meal also carried more protein and about three times the fibre. The card adds that this was one meal pair and that the authors urge caution in extending it to other meals.
Why
Barr and Wright (Food & Nutrition Research, 2010) matched their two cheese-sandwich meals for calories only. The whole-food meal was 20% protein and 40% carbohydrate against 15% and 50% for the processed one, with about three times the fibre, and the breads and cheeses differed by design. The paper measured the energy spent after eating, not how much nutrition the body extracts, and its authors ask for caution in extending a single meal comparison to other meals. Our error: the study's research brief described the meals as matched for macronutrients, and the page repeated the brief instead of the paper.
The paper
Barr SB, Wright JC. Postprandial energy expenditure in whole-food and processed-food meals: implications for daily energy expenditure. Food Nutr Res. 2010;54:5144.Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.

Newer day: September 26, 2026Older day: September 24, 2026The whole log

The full picture

How every claim on FitChef is checked, page by page.

We did the thinking. You just eat.

Get my week

It takes a minute.

ListenListen0:00Help