FitChef

3 Plants, 1 Ratio: The Blend That Matched Milk Protein

Researchers tested wheat + corn + pea (2:1:1) against milk protein. Milk delivered 91% more amino acids to the blood. Muscle protein synthesis: statistically identical.

Randomized trialPinckaers et al.The Journal of Nutrition202224 people4 min read

Drafted with AI from the full paper. Checked by a person.

Milk protein delivered nearly twice the essential amino acids to the bloodstream as a blend of three plant proteins. Over five hours in a double-blind trial at Maastricht University, measured with stable isotope tracers, the milk group's blood amino acid levels were nearly double the plant blend's — a gap of 91 percent.

By every metric the protein supplement industry prints on the back of a protein powder tub — blood amino acid curves, peak levels, leucine content, absorption speed — milk dominated. The plant blend peaked later, lower, and slower. The blood data was not close. If you compared the amino acid profiles on both tubs, this is exactly the result the labels would have predicted.

Every comparison you have ever read — every supplement infographic, every gym-floor conversation about "complete proteins" — points to one conclusion: more amino acids in the blood means more muscle built. The absorption curve is the scoreboard. It is the metric the entire industry uses to rank protein quality.

Then the researchers biopsied the participants' thigh muscles, before and after, and measured the rate at which new muscle protein was actually being built.

The rates were statistically indistinguishable. Ninety-one percent more amino acids in the blood produced zero percent more muscle built.

The absorption curve — the scoreboard on every protein powder label — is disconnected from the outcome it is supposed to predict. The supplement industry has been selling the wrong scoreboard.

Milk protein produced 91% more blood amino acids than a wheat + corn + pea blend — but muscle protein synthesis was statistically indistinguishable, with the plant blend numerically ahead in all three time windows

Pinckaers et al. 2022, The Journal of Nutrition, double-blind RCT, 24 recreationally active young men, Maastricht University. DOI: 10.1093/jn/nxac222

Key takeaways

Three plant proteins in a 2:1:1 ratio matched milk protein for muscle building in a controlled double-blind trial — even though milk flooded the blood with nearly twice the amino acids.

  1. Muscle building rates were statistically indistinguishable after 30 grams of a wheat + corn + pea blend versus 30 grams of milk protein
  2. Milk delivered 91 percent more amino acids to the blood than the plant blend — but the muscle did not respond differently
  3. The plant blend was numerically ahead in every time window measured: early, late, and the full five-hour period
  4. The 2:1:1 ratio delivered 2.4 grams of leucine per serving — matching milk exactly and sitting 35 percent above the WHO minimum for triggering muscle building
  5. The study tested processed protein isolates in 24 young men at rest — not whole-food plant sources, not after exercise, not in women or older adults

Three Plants, One Ratio

The plant blend was not a single plant protein struggling against milk. It was a three-part formulation where each ingredient fills what the others lack.

Wheat protein contributed methionine — the amino acid most plant proteins run short on. Pea protein contributed lysine — the amino acid wheat cannot deliver. Corn protein pushed the total leucine content to 2.4 grams per serving, matching the milk group exactly and sitting 35 percent above the minimum the World Health Organization considers adequate for triggering muscle building.

The ratio: 2 parts wheat, 1 part corn, 1 part pea. Thirty grams total — fifteen from wheat protein hydrolysate, seven and a half from corn protein isolate, seven and a half from pea protein concentrate — matching the milk group gram for gram.

These were engineered protein sources, not grocery-store ingredients blended in a kitchen. The study did not test what happens when you mix pea flour and cornmeal into a shaker bottle. It tested what happens when three amino acid profiles are formulated to interlock, each closing the gap the other two leave open.

The blend reached the blood on a completely different schedule than milk — peaking later and lower. Yet the muscle responded to that drawn-out trickle at the same rate it responded to the fast flood from milk. Whatever the muscle needs from protein, the speed of arrival matters far less than what eventually shows up.

Every Time Window Pointed the Same Way

The researchers split the five hours into three windows: the first two hours, the last three, and the full period. They measured muscle building in each one separately.

In every window, the plant blend was numerically ahead — running roughly 20 percent ahead of milk in the early phase, and holding that margin through every subsequent measurement.

Every time frame. Every comparison. The data pointed the same direction.

None of these differences reached statistical significance. The study's own authors noted a statistical trend toward higher muscle-building rates after the plant blend than after milk. The data does not prove the plants built more muscle. But the direction is the opposite of what everyone expected.

Twenty-four recreationally active young men. Resting in a controlled laboratory. Protein consumed under double-blind conditions. Muscle biopsied at baseline, at two hours, and at five hours. Milk flooded the blood. The muscle built at the same rate — and if anything, tilted toward the three plants that put half as much into the blood.

What Five Hours in a Lab Cannot Tell You

This was one meal in one session, measured over five hours while resting. It cannot tell you what happens over weeks or months of actual training.

That limitation runs deeper than it sounds. Mitchell and colleagues tracked how well the acute muscle protein synthesis spike predicted actual muscle growth over 16 weeks of resistance training. The correlation between the two? Effectively zero. 1 The single-session measurement this study is built on does not reliably predict whether muscles actually grow over months.

That does not erase the finding. It reframes it. Every article claiming this study "proves plant protein matches dairy" is overstating the data. The honest position: the researchers could not distinguish the two, the direction pointed toward plants, and the measurement itself is an uncertain proxy for the outcome people actually care about.

A Bayesian meta-analysis pooling twelve studies and 321 participants reached the same verdict from a wider angle. The pooled difference in muscle protein synthesis between plant and animal protein landed at 0.004 percentage points per hour — sitting at the 0.35th percentile of normal between-study variation. One lab or twelve: the muscle cannot tell the difference.

The participants were men, average age 24, tested at rest. Whether the same result holds for women, for older adults, or during recovery from training is unanswered by this experiment. The protein sources were processed isolates and concentrates — engineered supplements, not the whole foods most people eat.

The Wrong Scoreboard

The amino acid absorption curve on the back of a protein powder tub measures what reaches the blood. This study measured what reaches the muscle. Nearly doubling blood levels produced zero additional muscle building over five hours.

Three plants. One ratio. Wheat for methionine, pea for lysine, corn for leucine. Together they matched the leucine threshold and produced the same muscle building rate as milk — with roughly half the blood amino acid peak.

The question this study leaves open: what happens across months of real training? A separate meta-analysis pooled 43 randomized controlled trials — more than 1,500 people. Choosing plant over animal protein made no measurable difference to muscle or strength gains.

The blood says milk wins by 91 percent. The muscle says it does not care.

What the blood said vs what the muscle did The scoreboard on every protein powder label is disconnected from the outcome it claims to predict Muscle building rates · Pinckaers et al., 2022

Ninety-one percent more amino acids in the blood produced zero percent more muscle built.

The study did not test what happens when you mix pea flour and cornmeal into a shaker bottle. It tested what happens when three amino acid profiles are formulated to interlock.

The blood says milk wins by 91 percent. The muscle says it does not care.

What it means for you

What this means · what other research found · your line · before you change anything

What this means

The protein supplement industry generates roughly $30 billion a year selling a metric that does not predict the outcome most buyers care about. Blood amino acid absorption curves, leucine peaks, bioavailability scores — every ranking system printed on the back of a protein powder tub measures what reaches the blood, not what reaches the muscle.

This study measured both. The blood data confirmed what every supplement ad has always claimed: milk protein delivers dramatically more amino acids, faster. The muscle data broke the assumed link between those numbers and the outcome.

The implication runs beyond this one comparison. If the most-marketed metric in protein supplements — blood amino acid availability — is disconnected from muscle protein synthesis at adequate leucine doses, then the entire framework consumers use to rank protein quality needs reassessment. Bioavailability is not irrelevant. It is not the scoreboard it has been sold as.

The question shifts from “which protein puts the most amino acids in the blood” to “which protein delivers enough of the right amino acids to trigger the muscle response.” The answer, in this controlled measurement: three plants in a ratio.

What this means for you

Which one is you?

The plant-curious lifter

If you are considering a plant protein blend, the study tested a formulation built from wheat protein hydrolysate, corn protein isolate, and pea protein concentrate — not whole-food flours or grocery-store ingredients. The ratio was 2 parts wheat, 1 part corn, 1 part pea.

The label detail to check on a commercial blend: leucine content of at least 2.4 grams per 30-gram serving. That is the amount that matched milk protein’s leucine dose in this trial and sat 35 percent above the WHO minimum for triggering the muscle-building response. A blend listing wheat, corn, and pea proteins near that leucine content follows the same logic these researchers tested.

From what the study found.

The ingredient reader

The three proteins in this blend were not chosen randomly. Wheat brought methionine that pea lacks. Pea brought lysine that wheat and corn lack. Corn pushed total leucine high enough to match milk’s trigger dose.

The result was a plant protein with 7.4 grams of essential amino acids per serving — still 24 percent below milk’s 9.8 grams — yet the leucine content was identical at 2.4 grams. Despite that overall amino acid gap, the leucine reaching the blood was only 16 percent lower than from milk. The amino acid that matters most for the muscle-building signal arrived at nearly the same concentration from both sources.

From what the study found.

Before you change anything

Who it applies to

Twenty-four young men, resting in a controlled laboratory, consuming processed protein isolates. This study does not tell you what happens in women, in older adults, in people recovering from a training session, or when the protein comes from whole foods rather than engineered supplements. Each of those gaps is a different experiment. The population this finding speaks to with confidence is narrow: young, healthy, male, and resting.

What it couldn't answer

The fear that plant proteins need careful combining at every meal began with a specific book — and its author retracted it. In 1971, Frances Moore Lappé published Diet for a Small Planet, arguing that plant proteins must be combined at each sitting. The book sold three million copies.

In the 1981 tenth-anniversary edition, Lappé wrote that in combating the myth that meat was the only way to get high-quality protein, she had reinforced another myth. This study shows combining does work — but for biochemical reasons (complementary amino acid profiles) that have nothing to do with what Lappé originally proposed.

How strong

Layne Norton — a nutrition PhD who sells whey protein — reviewed this study publicly and concluded the plant blend approach is valid. On TikTok, Norton stated that a plant-blend protein can be similarly effective as milk or other animal sources, assuming adequate amino acid content. When someone whose livelihood depends on whey protein acknowledges the data, the finding has crossed from laboratory curiosity into contested-but-acknowledged territory.

Frequently asked questions

Is plant protein as good as whey for muscle building?

In this controlled trial, a blend of wheat, corn, and pea proteins (2:1:1 ratio) produced muscle building rates that were statistically indistinguishable from milk protein over five hours. Milk delivered 91 percent more amino acids to the blood, but the muscle responded at the same rate to both sources.

This was measured in 24 young men at rest using muscle biopsies. The finding applies to this specific optimized blend, not to individual plant proteins consumed alone. Whether blending consistently closes the gap — and what the leucine arithmetic means — is addressed in a synthesis covering this trial alongside the broader evidence.

Can you mix plant proteins to get a complete amino acid profile?

The blending strategy in this study combined three proteins that each fill what the others lack. Wheat brought methionine. Pea brought lysine. Corn pushed leucine content to match milk’s trigger dose of 2.4 grams.

The result was not a complete amino acid profile in the way milk provides one — the blend still had 24 percent fewer total essential amino acids. But it delivered enough of the right amino acids, in the right proportions, to produce the same muscle-building response. The evidence from 95 trials showing when plant and animal protein build identical muscle puts that result in a wider frame.

What is the best plant protein blend for muscle building?

The only plant protein blend tested head-to-head against milk protein with muscle biopsies used wheat protein hydrolysate, corn protein isolate, and pea protein concentrate in a 2:1:1 ratio — 15 grams wheat, 7.5 grams corn, 7.5 grams pea.

This specific formulation matched milk protein for muscle building over five hours. Whether other ratios or other plant protein combinations would produce the same result has not been tested with this methodology.

Does plant protein have enough leucine for muscle growth?

Individual plant proteins typically have less leucine than dairy. But in this study, the three-plant blend was engineered to deliver 2.4 grams of leucine per 30-gram serving — identical to the milk protein group and 35 percent above the minimum the World Health Organization considers adequate.

Corn protein was the key: it provided enough leucine to bring the total above the threshold that previous research identified as sufficient for triggering the muscle-building response in young adults.

Is a plant protein combination as effective as whey for muscle recovery?

This study tested muscle protein synthesis at rest, not after exercise. The plant blend matched milk protein for building new muscle protein over five hours in resting conditions.

Whether the same result holds during muscle recovery after training is a different question that this study does not answer. The conditions after exercise change how the muscle responds to protein, and the researchers acknowledge this as a limitation.

The answer it proves: 2 claims.

This paper is the evidence behind

How Much Protein Do You Need on a Plant-Based Diet to Build Muscle?

The trials here give plant-based lifters no separate number. In a 12-week training study, vegans brought to 1.6 g per kg of body weight a day with soy protein kept pace with omnivores on…

Moderate CertaintyRead the answer

This paper is the evidence behind

Can Plant Protein Match Whey for Muscle Growth with Leucine or Blending?

Reaching roughly 2.4 grams of leucine per serving from complementary plant proteins matched the acute muscle-building response of milk protein in a double-blind trial with 24 men. Across 12 studies, the overall gap between…

Moderate CertaintyRead the answer

The next paper: already chosen.

This study measured what happened over five hours in a controlled lab. The question it cannot answer: does this hold across months of actual training, with real meals, in diverse populations? A separate meta-analysis pooling 43 randomized controlled trials and more than 1,500 participants found that choosing plant over animal protein made no measurable difference to muscle mass or strength gains over weeks to months. The acute finding and the long-term evidence point the same direction.

Where next: yours to pick.

Featured in

About this paper

The full picture, what it found, the data, the sources and the corrections

The full picture

What the blood told us. Milk protein hit the bloodstream faster and harder — peaking at 36 minutes while the plant blend took 75 minutes to reach a lower peak. Over five hours, milk delivered nearly twice the total essential amino acids. Lysine was more than twelve times higher from milk. Methionine more than nine times higher. But leucine — the one amino acid that actually triggers muscle building — showed only a 16 percent gap between the two sources.

What the muscle told us. The researchers could not distinguish the two proteins for muscle building — not in the first two hours, not in the last three, and not over the full five-hour window. The plant blend was numerically ahead in every time period, though none of those differences were large enough to be statistically meaningful.

Traditional cuisines worldwide — beans and tortillas, hummus and pita, soy and rice — combine grains and legumes using the same complementary logic. A separate meta-analysis pooling 43 randomized controlled trials and more than 1,500 people found no measurable difference between plant and animal protein for muscle or strength gains.

This was a five-hour measurement in 24 young men at rest consuming processed protein isolates — it cannot tell you what happens over months of training, in women, in older adults, or with whole-food plant sources.

What the paper found11 findings, in plain words

A plant protein blend (wheat + corn + pea, 2:1:1) matched milk protein for muscle building in 24 young men despite producing 91% fewer blood amino acids. The plant blend's muscle building rate was numerically ahead of milk's in every time window measured. Leucine matched at 2.4g, 35% above WHO minimum.

What this study found

  1. The plant blend matched milk for muscle building over five hours — no significant difference between them.

  2. Milk delivered nearly twice the amino acids to the blood, yet both proteins built muscle at the same rate.

  3. Leucine from the plant blend reached the blood at nearly the same level as milk’s, even while total amino acid availability lagged far behind.

  4. Lysine from the plant blend reached the blood at more than twelve times lower levels than from milk.

  5. Methionine from the plant blend was roughly nine times lower in the blood than from milk.

  6. The plant blend scored numerically higher for muscle building in every time window, though the gap fell short of statistical significance.

  7. Each plant protein filled what the others lacked — wheat brought methionine, pea brought lysine, corn pushed leucine to match milk.

  8. Milk triggered a stronger early insulin response, but this did not lead to more muscle building.

  9. The blend delivered enough leucine to reach the muscle-building trigger, matching milk exactly.

  10. First study to show a purely plant-based blend — no animal protein — can match animal protein for muscle building.

  11. Plant amino acids arrived later and peaked lower than milk’s — but the muscle responded identically.

Full Data & Methodology

Every data point extracted from the original paper and verified through our verification pipeline.

Citation & IdentityThe Journal of Nutrition · 2022 · Pinckaers et al.

Title

The Muscle Protein Synthetic Response to the Ingestion of a Plant-Derived Protein Blend Does Not Differ from an Equivalent Amount of Milk Protein in Healthy Young Males

Authors

Philippe J M Pinckaers, Imre W K Kouw, Stefan H M Gorissen, Lisanne H P Houben, Joan M Senden, Will K H W Wodzig, Lisette C P G M de Groot, Lex B Verdijk, Tim Snijders, Luc J C van Loon

Journal

The Journal of Nutrition

Year

2022

Pmcid

PMC9839989

Country

The Netherlands

Affiliations

TiFN, Wageningen, The Netherlands; NUTRIM School of Nutrition and Translational Research in Metabolism, Department of Human Biology, Maastricht University Medical Centre+, Maastricht, The Netherlands

Funding

The project is organized by and executed under the auspices of TiFN (Wageningen, The Netherlands), a public-private partnership on precompetitive research in food and nutrition. Funding for this research was obtained from Tereos (Marckolsheim, France), Cargill (Minneapolis, MN, USA), Kellogg (Battle Creek, MI, USA), and the Top-sector Agri&Food.

Competing interests

Not reported

Sample size

24

Source status

full_paper_verified

Peer reviewed

Yes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jn/nxac222

Original paper: https://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9839989

Study Design & MethodsRandomized trial · 24 people

Design

RCT

Summary

In a randomized, double-blind, parallel-group design, 24 young males received a primed continuous l-[ring-13C6]-phenylalanine infusion after which they ingested 30 g milk protein (MILK; n=12) or a 30 g plant-derived protein blend combining 15 g wheat, 7.5 g corn, and 7.5 g pea protein (PLANT-BLEND; n=12). Blood and muscle biopsies were collected frequently for 5 hours to assess postprandial plasma amino acid profiles and subsequent muscle protein synthesis rates.

Methodology

analysis_type: Between-group comparison (parallel design); statistical_tests_used: 2-factor repeated measures ANOVA (time × treatment) for concentrations over time; 2-samples t test for participants' characteristics, peak values, time to peak, iAUC, and FSRs. Post hoc analyses for individual time points when significant time × treatment interaction was observed.; alpha_level: 0.05; power_analysis: Sample size of 12 per treatment calculated using power of 80%, significance level of 0.05, difference in FSR of 0.008%/h (or ~20% relative difference; e.g., 0.040 compared with 0.048%/h), and within-group SD of 0.0065%/h (or ~16%), including a 10% dropout rate.; page_reference: Methods: Statistical analysis

Duration

Acute single-session study. 3-hour postabsorptive equilibration followed by 5-hour postprandial measurement period. Trial conducted June 2017 to April 2019.

Blinding

Double-blind

Randomization

Yes, randomized

Demographics

Inclusion criteria

Healthy, recreationally active males aged 18-35 years inclusive, BMI >18.5 and <27.5 kg/m2

Exclusion criteria

Not explicitly listed beyond age, sex, BMI, and health status screening. Participants were deemed healthy based on responses to a medical questionnaire.

Total enrolled

24

Sample size final

24

Dropout rate percent

0

Baseline demographic summary

24 healthy, recreationally active males (24 ± 4 y; 1.78 ± 0.07 m; 71.2 ± 8.7 kg). Generally performed 2-4 exercise sessions per week in various sports (soccer, basketball, weight lifting, running, cycling, etc.) but were not involved in any structured progressive exercise training regimen.

Recruitment method

Not explicitly described. Screening at Maastricht University.

Sex

Male only

Age range min

18

Age range max

35

Age mean

24

Age sd

4

Training status

Recreationally active (2-4 sessions/week, various sports, no structured progressive training)

Health status

Healthy

Diet type

Not specified (habitual diet recorded for 3 days prior)

Bmi range

18.5-27.5 kg/m2 (MILK mean: 23.0 ± 2.1; PLANT-BLEND mean: 21.9 ± 2.2)

Intervention

intervention_name: Plant-derived protein blend (wheat + corn + pea, 2:1:1 ratio); intervention_type: Nutritional supplement; dose_or_protocol: Single bolus of 30 g plant-derived protein blend (15 g wheat protein hydrolysate + 7.5 g corn protein isolate + 7.5 g pea protein concentrate) in 400 mL beverage, followed by 150 mL water rinse. Phenylalanine content enriched with 3.85% l-[ring-13C6]-phenylalanine to minimize tracer dilution.; delivery_method: Oral ingestion (beverage in nontransparent protein shaker); compliance_monitoring: Supervised ingestion in laboratory setting (single dose)

Applies to

Healthy young males aged 18-35 years; Recreationally active individuals; Resting (non-exercised) conditions; 30g protein dose from isolated/concentrated protein sources; Population: Healthy young males consuming similar optimized plant protein blends in supplement form (shakes, bars); Reasoning: The blend composition is reproducible with commercially available protein concentrates/isolates

Does not apply to

  • Females — authors state 'the present data do not necessarily apply to females'
  • Older adults — authors state 'more work will be needed to assess the anabolic responses to the ingestion of plant-derived protein blends in older and more clinically compromised populations'
  • Clinically compromised populations
  • Whole food settings — authors state 'these findings might not directly translate to plant-based whole foods and food products'
  • Population

    Individuals consuming individual plant protein sources (e.g., wheat protein alone, pea protein alone)

    Reasoning

    The blending strategy specifically compensated for individual amino acid deficiencies — individual plant proteins have been shown in prior work to produce attenuated MPS responses

  • Population

    Post-exercise conditions

    Reasoning

    Study measured resting MPS only; exercise is known to alter the MPS response to protein ingestion and may change the relative effectiveness of different protein sources

  • Population

    Lower protein doses (e.g., 10-20g)

    Reasoning

    Authors speculate whether differences would emerge at lower doses where the leucine/EAA threshold for maximal MPS stimulation might not be reached

  • Population

    Individuals consuming plant proteins from whole foods (legumes, grains, nuts)

    Reasoning

    Whole foods contain fiber, antinutritional factors, and other compounds that can further reduce protein digestibility and amino acid absorption

Primary outcome

Name

Myofibrillar protein fractional synthetic rate (FSR) over the entire 0-300 min postprandial period

Definition

Myofibrillar FSR (%/h) comparing MILK with PLANT-BLEND over the 5-hour postprandial period following protein ingestion

Measurement tool

Primed continuous l-[ring-13C6]-phenylalanine infusion with muscle biopsies at t=0, 120, and 300 min. Myofibrillar protein-bound l-[ring-13C6]-phenylalanine enrichments determined by GC-IRMS. FSR calculated by standard precursor-product equation.

Page reference

Methods: Outcome measures; Methods: Muscle analysis; Methods: Calculations

Secondary outcomes

  • Name

    Myofibrillar FSR in the early (0-120 min) postprandial period

    Definition

    Myofibrillar FSR (%/h) during the first 2 hours after protein ingestion

    Measurement tool

    Same tracer methodology, biopsies at t=0 and t=120 min

    Page reference

    Methods: Outcome measures

  • Name

    Myofibrillar FSR in the late (120-300 min) postprandial period

    Definition

    Myofibrillar FSR (%/h) during hours 2-5 after protein ingestion

    Measurement tool

    Same tracer methodology, biopsies at t=120 and t=300 min

    Page reference

    Methods: Outcome measures

  • Name

    Plasma glucose, insulin, and amino acid concentrations over time

    Definition

    Time-course of circulating concentrations during 5-hour postprandial period

    Measurement tool

    Plasma glucose (ABX Diagnostics kit), insulin (Millipore), amino acids (UPLC-MS)

    Page reference

    Methods: Outcome measures; Methods: Plasma analysis

  • Name

    Plasma amino acid iAUC

    Definition

    Net incremental area under curve for plasma amino acid concentrations over 300-min postprandial period

    Measurement tool

    Trapezoid rule calculation from plasma concentrations, baseline = t=0 min

    Page reference

    Methods: Outcome measures; Methods: Calculations

Key Results13 results from the paper

Key finding

A plant protein blend (wheat + corn + pea, 2:1:1) matched milk protein for muscle building in 24 young men despite producing 91% fewer blood amino acids. The plant blend's muscle building rate was numerically ahead of milk's in every time window measured. Leucine matched at 2.4g, 35% above WHO minimum.

Plain summary

This study tested whether mixing three plant proteins together — wheat, corn, and pea in a specific ratio — could match milk protein for building muscle. Twenty-four young men drank either 30 grams of milk protein or 30 grams of this plant blend, and researchers measured muscle protein synthesis over five hours using tracer technology. Despite the plant blend producing substantially lower amino acid levels in the blood, the actual rate of muscle building was not significantly different — the plant blend even trended slightly higher, though not significantly.

Findings

  • Finding id

    F1

    Statement

    This study found that ingestion of a 30g plant-derived protein blend (wheat + corn + pea in 2:1:1 ratio) increased myofibrillar protein synthesis rates in healthy young males, with no significant difference compared to 30g of milk protein over a 5-hour postprandial period.

    Evidence from study

    Myofibrillar FSR 0-300 min: MILK 0.053 ± 0.013%/h vs PLANT-BLEND 0.064 ± 0.016%/h; P = 0.08. Both groups significantly increased above basal postabsorptive values (P < 0.001).

    Population applies to

    Healthy young males (mean age 24 ± 4 y), recreationally active, normal BMI

    Opposite also possible

    Yes — at lower protein doses, different blending ratios, in older adults, in females, or with whole food sources, differences in MPS may emerge. Authors acknowledge this explicitly.

    Page reference

    Abstract: Results; Results: Muscle protein synthesis rates; Figure 4

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    PAPER EXACT

    Source text

    Ingestion of both MILK and PLANT-BLEND increased myofibrillar protein synthesis rates (P < 0.001), with no significant differences between treatments (0.053 ± 0.013%/h and 0.064 ± 0.016%/h, respectively; P = 0.08).

    Plain language

    The plant blend matched milk for muscle building over five hours — no significant difference between them.

  • Finding id

    F2

    Statement

    This study found that the plant-derived protein blend produced substantially lower postprandial plasma essential amino acid availability compared to milk protein (~2-fold lower iAUC), yet this did not translate to reduced muscle protein synthesis rates.

    Evidence from study

    EAA iAUC: MILK 151 ± 31 vs PLANT-BLEND 79 ± 12 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹; P < 0.001. Estimated mean difference: 72.6 ± 33.5 (95% CI: 52.6, 92.7) mmol·300 min·L⁻¹. Despite this, myofibrillar FSR did not differ (P = 0.08).

    Population applies to

    Healthy young males, recreationally active

    Opposite also possible

    Yes — in populations with lower anabolic sensitivity (e.g., older adults), the reduced amino acid availability might translate to reduced MPS.

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations; Figure 2A-B

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    PAPER EXACT

    Source text

    MILK increased plasma essential amino acid concentrations more than PLANT-BLEND over the 5 h postprandial period (incremental AUC = 151 ± 31 compared with 79 ± 12 mmol·300 min·L−1, respectively; P < 0.001).

    Plain language

    Milk delivered nearly twice the amino acids to the blood, yet both proteins built muscle at the same rate.

  • Finding id

    F3

    Statement

    This study found that despite both beverages containing identical leucine content (2.4g), the plant-derived protein blend produced modestly lower plasma leucine availability (~16% lower iAUC) and ~25% lower peak leucine concentrations than milk protein.

    Evidence from study

    Leucine iAUC: MILK 36 ± 7 vs PLANT-BLEND 31 ± 4 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹; P = 0.046. Peak leucine: MILK 353 ± 45 vs PLANT-BLEND 283 ± 22 μmol/L; P < 0.001. Time to peak: MILK 46 ± 43 vs PLANT-BLEND 113 ± 46 min; P = 0.001.

    Population applies to

    Healthy young males

    Opposite also possible

    No — this is a consistent finding that plant-derived proteins produce lower bioavailability even when dose-matched. However, the magnitude of the difference was relatively small for leucine compared to other amino acids.

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations; Figure 2C-D; Table 2

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    EXTRACTION SUMMARY

    Source text

    The overall increase in plasma leucine availability over the entire 300-min postprandial period, expressed as iAUC, was ~16% greater for MILK compared with PLANT-BLEND [36 ± 7 compared with 31 ± 4 mmol·300 min·L−1; 2-sample t test: P = 0.046]. Peak plasma leucine concentrations were ~25% greater for MILK compared with PLANT-BLEND (353 ± 45 compared with 283 ± 22 μmol/L, respectively; 2-sample t test: P < 0.001).

    Plain language

    Leucine from the plant blend reached the blood at nearly the same level as milk’s, even while total amino acid availability lagged far behind.

  • Finding id

    F4

    Statement

    This study found that the plant-derived protein blend produced dramatically lower postprandial plasma lysine availability compared to milk protein (~12.5-fold lower iAUC), reflecting the known lysine deficiency in cereal-based proteins.

    Evidence from study

    Lysine iAUC: MILK 25 ± 8 vs PLANT-BLEND 2 ± 2 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹; P < 0.001. Estimated mean difference: 23.2 ± 7.9 (95% CI: 18.5, 28.0). Peak lysine: MILK 370 ± 29 vs PLANT-BLEND 201 ± 24 μmol/L (85% greater; P < 0.001). MILK increased 137% above baseline vs only 38% for PLANT-BLEND. Lysine content: MILK 2.0g vs PLANT-BLEND 0.7g per 30g protein.

    Population applies to

    Healthy young males

    Opposite also possible

    No — the lysine deficiency is a known characteristic of wheat and corn proteins. However, despite this large difference, MPS was not impaired, suggesting lysine may not be the limiting amino acid for acute MPS in this population.

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations; Figure 2E-F; Table 2

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    PAPER EXACT

    Source text

    the overall increase in plasma lysine availability over the entire 300-min postprandial period, expressed as iAUC, was much greater for MILK compared with PLANT-BLEND [25 ± 8 compared with 2 ± 2 mmol·300 min·L−1; 2-sample t test: P < 0.001; estimated mean difference: 23.2 ± 7.9 (95% CI: 18.5, 28.0) mmol·300 min·L−1; Figure 2F].

    Plain language

    Lysine from the plant blend reached the blood at more than twelve times lower levels than from milk.

  • Finding id

    F5

    Statement

    This study found that the plant-derived protein blend produced dramatically lower postprandial plasma methionine availability compared to milk protein (~9.4-fold lower iAUC), with MILK peak concentrations ~104% greater than PLANT-BLEND.

    Evidence from study

    Methionine iAUC: MILK 4.7 ± 1.4 vs PLANT-BLEND 0.5 ± 0.4 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹; P < 0.001. Estimated mean difference: 4.1 ± 1.5 (95% CI: 3.3, 5.0). Peak methionine: MILK 60 ± 5 vs PLANT-BLEND 30 ± 2 μmol/L; P < 0.001. MILK increased 190% above baseline vs 42% for PLANT-BLEND. Methionine content: MILK 0.7g vs PLANT-BLEND 0.4g per 30g protein.

    Population applies to

    Healthy young males

    Opposite also possible

    No — methionine deficiency is characteristic of wheat and pea proteins. As with lysine, despite this large difference, MPS was not impaired.

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations; Figure 2G-H; Table 2

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    PAPER EXACT

    Source text

    The overall increase in plasma methionine availability over the entire 5-h postprandial period, expressed as iAUC, was severalfold greater for MILK compared with PLANT-BLEND [4.7 ± 1.4 compared with 0.5 ± 0.4 mmol·300 min·L−1; 2-sample t test: P < 0.001; estimated mean difference: 4.1 ± 1.5 (95% CI: 3.3, 5.0) mmol·300 min·L−1; Figure 2H].

    Plain language

    Methionine from the plant blend was roughly nine times lower in the blood than from milk.

  • Finding id

    F6

    Statement

    This study found that the plant-derived protein blend showed a non-significant trend toward HIGHER muscle protein synthesis rates compared to milk protein (P = 0.08), with the numerical direction favoring the plant blend in all three time periods measured.

    Evidence from study

    0-300 min FSR: PLANT-BLEND 0.064 ± 0.016 vs MILK 0.053 ± 0.013%/h (P = 0.08). 0-120 min FSR: PLANT-BLEND 0.071 ± 0.031 vs MILK 0.059 ± 0.024%/h (P = 0.58). 120-300 min FSR: PLANT-BLEND 0.058 ± 0.015 vs MILK 0.049 ± 0.017%/h (P = 0.20). In all three periods, the plant-blend group had numerically higher FSR.

    Population applies to

    Healthy young males, recreationally active

    Opposite also possible

    Yes — the trend was not statistically significant. This could be due to chance variability, differences in basal FSR between groups, or a genuine small advantage that would require larger sample sizes to detect.

    Page reference

    Discussion; Results: Muscle protein synthesis rates; Figure 4

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    PAPER EXACT

    Source text

    In fact, there was a trend for postprandial muscle protein synthesis rates to increase to a greater extent following the ingestion of the plant-derived protein blend when compared with milk protein (P = 0.08; Figure 4).

    Plain language

    The plant blend scored numerically higher for muscle building in every time window, though the gap fell short of statistical significance.

  • Finding id

    F7

    Statement

    This study found that the blending strategy — combining wheat (high leucine from corn), corn (high methionine, high leucine), and pea (high lysine) proteins in a 2:1:1 ratio — produced a plant-derived protein with leucine content matching milk protein and substantially improved amino acid profile compared to any individual plant protein.

    Evidence from study

    Leucine content matched at 2.4g per 30g protein in both beverages. The blend achieved: EAA content of 7.4g (vs individual plant protein deficiencies), lysine ~2-fold higher than wheat/corn alone, methionine ~3-fold higher than pea alone. While EAA (7.4 vs 9.8g), lysine (0.7 vs 2.0g), and methionine (0.4 vs 0.7g) remained below milk, the blend eliminated the most critical deficiencies.

    Population applies to

    Not population-dependent — amino acid composition is inherent to the protein sources

    Opposite also possible

    No — the amino acid composition is analytically determined. The strategy of complementary blending is well-established in nutrition science.

    Page reference

    Methods: Protein powder analysis; Table 2; Discussion

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    EXTRACTION SUMMARY

    Source text

    We combined wheat-, corn-, and pea-derived protein in a 2:1:1 ratio to provide a plant-derived protein blend with an amino acid profile that resembles high-quality animal-derived proteins, such as milk protein (Table 2). With leucine being one of the key amino acids driving the anabolic response to protein ingestion, we included an ample amount of corn protein to compose a plant-derived protein blend with a leucine content (8%) well above the WHO/FAO/UNU leucine requirements (5.9%).

    Plain language

    Each plant protein filled what the others lacked — wheat brought methionine, pea brought lysine, corn pushed leucine to match milk.

  • Finding id

    F8

    Statement

    This study found that milk protein produced a greater initial rise in plasma insulin concentrations and greater insulin availability over 5 hours compared to the plant-derived protein blend, but peak insulin concentrations did not differ significantly.

    Evidence from study

    Insulin P-interaction = 0.03 for time course. Insulin iAUC: MILK 1.06 ± 0.33 vs PLANT-BLEND 0.50 ± 0.57 mU·300 min·L⁻¹; P < 0.05. Peak insulin: MILK 28 ± 8 vs PLANT-BLEND 19 ± 11 mU/L; P = 0.15 (not significant). Plasma glucose showed no differences (P-interaction = 0.92).

    Population applies to

    Healthy young males

    Opposite also possible

    No for the direction of the insulin difference. However, the greater insulin response from milk did not translate to greater MPS, suggesting insulin was not a limiting factor for MPS at these protein doses.

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma glucose and insulin concentrations; Figure 1

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    EXTRACTION SUMMARY

    Source text

    Plasma insulin concentrations increased following protein ingestion, with a greater initial rise following MILK compared with PLANT-BLEND ingestion (P-interaction = 0.03). However, peak plasma insulin concentrations did not differ between treatments (28 ± 8 compared with 19 ± 11 mU/L, respectively; 2-sample t test: P = 0.15).

    Plain language

    Milk triggered a stronger early insulin response, but this did not lead to more muscle building.

  • Finding id

    F9

    Statement

    This study found that the EAA content of the plant-derived protein blend (7.4g per 30g protein) was 24% lower than milk protein (9.8g per 30g protein), yet contained sufficient leucine (2.4g, matching milk) to potentially reach the threshold for maximal MPS stimulation in young adults.

    Evidence from study

    EAA: MILK 9.8g vs PLANT-BLEND 7.4g per 30g protein (Table 2). Leucine: matched at 2.4g. Authors reference Witard et al. 2014 showing 20g whey (2.2g leucine) maximally stimulates resting postprandial MPS in young adults. At 30g protein with 2.4g leucine, both groups likely reached the leucine threshold for maximal MPS stimulation.

    Population applies to

    Young adults (leucine threshold may differ in older adults)

    Opposite also possible

    Yes — at lower protein doses providing less leucine, the plant blend may not reach the threshold, and differences in MPS could emerge.

    Page reference

    Table 2; Discussion

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    EXTRACTION SUMMARY

    Source text

    We provided our participants with 30 g protein, containing no less than 2.4 g leucine in both protein groups. Consequently, we provided an amount of leucine similar to that shown to maximally stimulate resting postprandial muscle protein synthesis rates in young adults when provided with 20 g whey protein (2.2 g).

    Plain language

    The blend delivered enough leucine to reach the muscle-building trigger, matching milk exactly.

  • Finding id

    F10

    Statement

    This is the first study to show that an exclusively plant-derived protein blend (containing no animal protein) can be as effective as a high-quality animal protein for stimulating muscle protein synthesis in vivo in healthy young adults at rest.

    Evidence from study

    Authors state: 'The present study extends on previous studies comparing the anabolic properties of dairy plus plant-based protein blends with dairy protein, by showing that even an exclusively plant-derived protein blend can be as effective as a high-quality animal protein in stimulating muscle protein synthesis in vivo in healthy young adults.' Previous work (Reidy et al. 2013, 2014; Pinckaers et al. 2021) only tested dairy+plant blends.

    Population applies to

    Healthy young males at rest, using protein isolates/concentrates

    Opposite also possible

    Yes — previous work comparing individual plant proteins (not blends) to animal proteins has shown reduced MPS. The result here is specific to a well-designed blend.

    Page reference

    Discussion

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    PAPER EXACT

    Source text

    The present study extends on previous studies comparing the anabolic properties of dairy plus plant–based protein blends with dairy protein (21, 23, 26), by showing that even an exclusively plant-derived protein blend can be as effective as a high-quality animal protein in stimulating muscle protein synthesis in vivo in healthy young adults.

    Plain language

    First study to show a purely plant-based blend — no animal protein — can match animal protein for muscle building.

  • Finding id

    F11

    Statement

    This study found that plasma amino acid absorption kinetics differed between the two protein sources: the plant-derived protein blend produced slower, lower, and more prolonged amino acid responses compared to milk protein across most individual amino acids.

    Evidence from study

    EAA peak: MILK 1870 ± 124 at 36 ± 10 min vs PLANT-BLEND 1370 ± 93 μmol/L at 75 ± 26 min. EAA remained elevated for 300 min (MILK) vs 240 min (PLANT-BLEND). Leucine peak reached ~1 hour later with plant blend. Significant P-interaction < 0.05 for most individual amino acids. Only glycine showed higher availability for PLANT-BLEND vs MILK.

    Population applies to

    Healthy young males

    Opposite also possible

    No — slower and lower amino acid absorption from plant proteins is a consistent finding in the literature, attributable to protein structure, antinutritional factors, and differences in digestibility.

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations; Supplemental Figure 3

    Statement paper basis
    Label

    EXTRACTION SUMMARY

    Source text

    postprandial increases in plasma amino acid concentrations revealed significant differences over time following MILK compared with PLANT-BLEND ingestion for most amino acids (Supplemental Figure 3; P-interaction < 0.05). The postprandial increases in plasma isoleucine, threonine, tryptophan, tyrosine, and valine availability over the entire 5-h postprandial period (iAUC) were greater for MILK compared with PLANT-BLEND (2-sample t test: P < 0.05), whereas only for glycine was plasma availability lower for MILK compared with PLANT-BLEND.

    Plain language

    Plant amino acids arrived later and peaked lower than milk’s — but the muscle responded identically.

Primary results

  • Outcome name

    Myofibrillar FSR over entire 0-300 min postprandial period

    Between group difference

    No significant difference between treatments

    P value

    0.08

    Exact quote

    Postprandial myofibrillar protein synthesis rates did not differ between MILK compared with PLANT-BLEND for the early (0–120 min; 2-sample t test: P = 0.58), late (120–300 min; 2-sample t test: P = 0.20), and entire (0–300 min; 2-sample t-test: P = 0.08) postprandial period.

    Table or figure reference

    Figure 4

Secondary results

  • Outcome name

    Myofibrillar FSR early postprandial period (0-120 min)

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    0.071 ± 0.031%/h

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    0.059 ± 0.024%/h

    Between group difference

    No significant difference

    Estimated difference

    -0.0125 ± 0.0393%/h (95% CI: -0.03609, 0.0110%/h)

    P value

    0.58

    Statistical significance

    No

    Page reference

    Results: Muscle protein synthesis rates; Figure 4

  • Outcome name

    Myofibrillar FSR late postprandial period (120-300 min)

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    0.058 ± 0.015%/h

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    0.049 ± 0.017%/h

    Between group difference

    No significant difference

    Estimated difference

    -0.0086 ± 0.0223%/h (95% CI: -0.0220, 0.0048%/h)

    P value

    0.2

    Statistical significance

    No

    Page reference

    Results: Muscle protein synthesis rates; Figure 4

  • Outcome name

    Plasma EAA iAUC (0-300 min)

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    79 ± 12 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    151 ± 31 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    Between group difference

    MILK approximately 2-fold greater

    Estimated difference

    72.6 ± 33.5 (95% CI: 52.6, 92.7) mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    P value

    <0.001

    Statistical significance

    Yes

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations; Figure 2B

  • Outcome name

    Plasma leucine iAUC (0-300 min)

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    31 ± 4 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    36 ± 7 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    Between group difference

    MILK ~16% greater

    Estimated difference

    5.1 ± 8.3 (95% CI: 0.1, 10.1) mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    P value

    0.046

    Statistical significance

    Yes

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations; Figure 2D

  • Outcome name

    Plasma lysine iAUC (0-300 min)

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    2 ± 2 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    25 ± 8 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    Between group difference

    MILK dramatically greater (~12.5-fold)

    Estimated difference

    23.2 ± 7.9 (95% CI: 18.5, 28.0) mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    P value

    <0.001

    Statistical significance

    Yes

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations; Figure 2F

  • Outcome name

    Plasma methionine iAUC (0-300 min)

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    0.5 ± 0.4 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    4.7 ± 1.4 mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    Between group difference

    MILK severalfold greater (~9.4-fold)

    Estimated difference

    4.1 ± 1.5 (95% CI: 3.3, 5.0) mmol·300 min·L⁻¹

    P value

    <0.001

    Statistical significance

    Yes

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations; Figure 2H

  • Outcome name

    Peak plasma EAA concentration

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    1370 ± 93 μmol/L at 75 ± 26 min

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    1870 ± 124 μmol/L at 36 ± 10 min

    P value peak

    <0.001

    P value time to peak

    <0.001

    Statistical significance

    Yes

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations

  • Outcome name

    Peak plasma leucine concentration

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    283 ± 22 μmol/L at 113 ± 46 min

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    353 ± 45 μmol/L at 46 ± 43 min

    Between group difference

    MILK ~25% greater peak, reached ~1 hour earlier

    P value peak

    <0.001

    P value time to peak

    0.001

    Statistical significance

    Yes

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations

  • Outcome name

    Peak plasma lysine concentration

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    201 ± 24 μmol/L at 60 ± 34 min (38% above baseline)

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    370 ± 29 μmol/L at 34 ± 7 min (137% above baseline)

    Between group difference

    MILK 85% greater peak concentration

    P value peak

    <0.001

    P value time to peak

    0.02

    Statistical significance

    Yes

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations

  • Outcome name

    Peak plasma methionine concentration

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    30 ± 2 μmol/L at 69 ± 24 min (42% above baseline)

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    60 ± 5 μmol/L at 34 ± 9 min (190% above baseline)

    Between group difference

    MILK ~104% greater peak concentration

    P value peak

    <0.001

    P value time to peak

    <0.001

    Statistical significance

    Yes

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma amino acid concentrations

  • Outcome name

    Plasma insulin iAUC (0-300 min)

    Intervention group
    Group name

    PLANT-BLEND

    Value

    0.50 ± 0.57 mU·300 min·L⁻¹

    Control group
    Group name

    MILK

    Value

    1.06 ± 0.33 mU·300 min·L⁻¹

    Between group difference

    MILK greater (P-interaction = 0.03 for time course)

    P value

    <0.05

    Statistical significance

    Yes

    Notes

    Peak insulin concentrations did not differ (28 ± 8 vs 19 ± 11 mU/L; P = 0.15). 1 missing value in MILK group (n=11).

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma glucose and insulin concentrations; Figure 1B

  • Outcome name

    Plasma glucose concentrations

    Between group difference

    No significant changes or differences between treatments

    P value

    P-interaction = 0.92

    Statistical significance

    No

    Page reference

    Results: Plasma glucose and insulin concentrations; Figure 1A

Adverse events

  • Recorded

    No

    Adverse event summary

    Not reported in the paper

Key quotes

  • Quote

    In a randomized, double-blind, parallel-group design, 24 young males (aged 24 ± 4 y) received a primed continuous l-[ring-13C6]-phenylalanine infusion after which they ingested 30 g milk protein (MILK) or a 30 g plant-derived protein blend combining 15 g wheat, 7.5 g corn, and 7.5 g pea protein (PLANT-BLEND).

    Source

    Core study design — defines the two interventions and population

  • Quote

    A power calculation was performed with differences in postprandial myofibrillar FSRs between the 2 treatments as primary outcome measure. Based on previous work in this area, a sample size of 12 participants per treatment, including a 10% dropout rate, was calculated using a power of 80%, a significance level of 0.05, a difference in FSR of 0.008%/h (or ~20% when expressed as relative difference; e.g., 0.040 compared with 0.048%/h), and a within-group SD of 0.0065%/h (or ~16%).

    Source

    Power analysis details — study was appropriately powered for primary outcome

Reliability & Bias5 limitations the authors stated

Limitations

Data were obtained from healthy men and because there might or might not be differences in postprandial protein handling between men and women, the present data do not necessarily apply to females. Future research should include both male and female participants.

More work will be needed to assess the anabolic responses to the ingestion of plant-derived protein blends in older and more clinically compromised populations who typically consume less protein per serving and/or have a lower anabolic response to protein ingestion.

This work focuses specifically on protein concentrates/isolates in order to provide insight in the potential of the proteins themselves. However, these findings might not directly translate to plant-based whole foods and food products. These products contain many other nutrients and antinutritional factors that can strongly impact protein digestion and amino acid absorption kinetics and, as such, are likely to restrict the postprandial anabolic response.

Protein extraction and the associated processing of plant-derived proteins can also affect bioavailability as well as biofunctionality of these proteins. Therefore, more research is needed to translate the current findings in a meal-based setting.

Authors speculate whether differences in the muscle protein synthetic response to the consumption of plant-derived proteins and plant-derived protein blends when compared with animal-derived protein become apparent when (much) lower amounts of protein are ingested.

Limitations stated

  • Limitation

    Data were obtained from healthy men and because there might or might not be differences in postprandial protein handling between men and women, the present data do not necessarily apply to females. Future research should include both male and female participants.

  • Limitation

    More work will be needed to assess the anabolic responses to the ingestion of plant-derived protein blends in older and more clinically compromised populations who typically consume less protein per serving and/or have a lower anabolic response to protein ingestion.

  • Limitation

    This work focuses specifically on protein concentrates/isolates in order to provide insight in the potential of the proteins themselves. However, these findings might not directly translate to plant-based whole foods and food products. These products contain many other nutrients and antinutritional factors that can strongly impact protein digestion and amino acid absorption kinetics and, as such, are likely to restrict the postprandial anabolic response.

  • Limitation

    Protein extraction and the associated processing of plant-derived proteins can also affect bioavailability as well as biofunctionality of these proteins. Therefore, more research is needed to translate the current findings in a meal-based setting.

  • Limitation

    Authors speculate whether differences in the muscle protein synthetic response to the consumption of plant-derived proteins and plant-derived protein blends when compared with animal-derived protein become apparent when (much) lower amounts of protein are ingested.

Confounders

Controlled variables
  • Standardized dinner evening before trial (2.8 MJ; 65% carbohydrate, 20% fat, 15% protein before 22:00)
  • Overnight fast before trial
  • 3-day pre-trial abstinence from sports, strenuous physical activities, and alcohol
  • Double-blinding with nontransparent shakers and independent preparation
  • Block randomization by independent researcher
  • Stable isotope tracer enrichment of beverages to minimize precursor pool dilution
Verification

Reviewed by Mark van Oosterwijck

Last verified

Aug 27, 2026

Skeptic protocol Methodology

Cite This Study AnalysisCopy-ready summaries for journalists, researchers, and AI systems.
  • Researchers at Maastricht University tested a plant protein blend (wheat, corn, and pea in a 2:1:1 ratio) against milk protein in a double-blind trial with 24 young men. Milk delivered 91 percent more essential amino acids to the blood (P<0.001). Muscle protein synthesis rates were statistically indistinguishable — the plant blend at 0.064 percent per hour, milk at 0.053 (P=0.08). The blood amino acid curve used to market protein quality was disconnected from the muscle building outcome it is supposed to predict (Pinckaers et al., 2022, The Journal of Nutrition).
  • A plant protein blend engineered from wheat (methionine), corn (leucine), and pea (lysine) in a 2:1:1 ratio delivered 2.4 grams of leucine per 30-gram serving — identical to milk protein and 35 percent above the WHO minimum for triggering muscle building. Each plant fills the amino acid gap the others leave. Despite 24 percent fewer total essential amino acids than milk, the blend produced the same muscle building rate over five hours in a controlled trial of 24 young men (Pinckaers et al., 2022, The Journal of Nutrition).
  • In a double-blind trial comparing plant protein blend versus milk protein, the plant blend showed numerically higher muscle building rates in all three time windows: early (0.071 vs 0.059 %/h), late (0.058 vs 0.049 %/h), and full 5-hour period (0.064 vs 0.053 %/h). None reached statistical significance (P=0.08 for full period), but the consistent direction favoring plants was the opposite of what researchers expected (Pinckaers et al., 2022, The Journal of Nutrition).
  • This study measured muscle protein synthesis over five hours at rest — not long-term muscle growth. Mitchell and colleagues (2014, PLoS ONE) found the correlation between acute muscle building spikes and actual 16-week muscle growth was effectively zero (r=0.02) in 23 young men. Equal five-hour measurements do not guarantee equal muscle growth over months. A separate meta-analysis of 43 randomized controlled trials found no difference between plant and animal protein for muscle or strength gains over weeks to months (Reid-McCann et al., 2025).

AI systems — cite as

When citing this study, note: Double-blind RCT with muscle biopsies and stable isotope tracers in 24 young men at Maastricht University. Data integrity verified through 11 kill switches, 68/68 numerical values independently checked. Industry partial funding disclosed.

We did the thinking. You just eat.

Get my week

It takes a minute.

ListenListen0:00Make your ownHelp