FitChef

The log: one day.

September 27, 2026

4 corrections on 6 pages. Most arrive together: one paper read again against every page that cites it, and every page fixed the same day.

A creatine Short called a review an '11-author expert panel' without its authors' ties to creatine makers

September 27, 2026 · We got it wrong

What it said
The Short credited Antonio et al. 2021 as an '11-author expert panel review' and did not mention the review's competing interests.
What it says now
It names them: five of the eleven authors serve on the scientific advisory board of Alzchem, a creatine manufacturer, and others have advised or received funding from companies that sell creatine; the paper lists its funding as not applicable.
Why
The review's competing-interests section lists these ties. A reader weighing a review of creatine's side effects should see them next to it. Our check of the review covered its findings but not its declarations.
The paper
Antonio J, et al. Common questions and misconceptions about creatine supplementation: what does the scientific evidence really show? J Int Soc Sports Nutr 2021;18:13.Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.
A creatine Short credited a 143-study meta-analysis to the wrong first author, journal and title

September 27, 2026 · We got it wrong

What it said
The Short credited the 143-study meta-analysis to 'Bonilla et al. 2024' in 'J Sports Sci Med', under the title 'Effects of creatine supplementation on body composition: a meta-analysis of 143 RCTs', and said 8 of its trials 'directly measured whether the body mass change was water or muscle tissue'.
What it says now
It credits Pashayee-Khamene et al. 2024, 'Creatine supplementation protocols with or without training interventions on body composition: a GRADE-assessed systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis', J Int Soc Sports Nutr 21(1):2380058, and says 8 of the 143 studies used bioelectrical impedance, a method that can estimate body water.
Why
The paper's first author is Fereshteh Pashayee-Khamene, and it appeared in the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition in 2024; Bonilla et al. is its first reference, a different review from 2021. The paper says 8 of 143 studies used BIA or provided body water data, and that more studies are needed to confirm body water changes; it does not say they settled water versus muscle. The Short's citation had been composed instead of copied from the paper. The same mistake was corrected on two claims and the supplements guide on 27 June 2026 (record 2026-06-27-creatine-meta-analysis-author-misattributed), but the Shorts were not checked then.
The paper
Pashayee-Khamene F, et al. J Int Soc Sports Nutr 2024;21(1):2380058.Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.
The creatine claim described a 2025 trial from news coverage instead of from the paper

September 27, 2026 · We got it wrong

What it said
The page said the 2025 UNSW trial tested '54 people who were not training seriously' and 'confirmed the one condition where creatine does not work — when there is no training stimulus', under a quoted headline that creatine 'makes no difference to muscle gains'.
What it says now
The page describes the trial as the paper reports it: 63 untrained adults took 5 g of creatine a day or nothing, first for a week without exercise, then through 12 weeks of supervised resistance training. After the first week the creatine group had gained 0.51 kg more lean mass; during the training both groups gained about 2 kg, with no difference between them. The authors think creatine's 'apparent' extra benefit is likely short-term, plausibly fluid, and suggest more than 5 g a day may be needed.
Why
Desai et al. 2025 (Nutrients 17(6):1081) randomised untrained adults, and both groups then trained under supervision three times a week for 12 weeks, so it was not a trial of people who did not train. Creatine's extra lean mass came in the one week without exercise before the training; during the training it added none. Our section had been written from news reports of the trial, not from the paper.
The paper
Desai I, et al. The Effect of Creatine Supplementation on Lean Body Mass with and Without Resistance Training. Nutrients 2025;17(6):1081.Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.
Six pages said the water creatine adds goes only into the muscle cells, 'not under the skin', and does not last

September 27, 2026 · We got it wrong

What it said
Six pages said the water creatine adds goes into the muscle cells and 'not under the skin' (on one Short, in its title), that it makes muscles look 'fuller, not bloated', and that it is temporary: 'a first-week event', with no lasting rise in total body water in training studies of 5 to 10 weeks. The study page for the 143-study meta-analysis said the water may be 'stored inside muscle cells'.
What it says now
The pages say that creatine raises total body water, that most of it is thought to sit inside cells and some outside them, and that in some short studies the water outside cells rose as well. Several training studies of 5 to 10 weeks found no rise in total body water, while a 28-day and an 8-week trial found one. None of the studies behind these pages measured puffiness.
Why
The papers say so. Burke et al. 2023: creatine 'increases total body water', and the majority of its hydrating effect is 'generally believed' to sit inside cells, which is not all of it. Pashayee-Khamene et al. 2024: part of the fat-free mass gain may be water retention '(both extra- and intracellular)', and more studies are needed to confirm it. Antonio et al. 2021: three days of creatine raised the water outside cells in one study; training studies of 5 to 10 weeks found no rise in total body water, but Powers et al. (28 days) and Ribeiro et al. (8 weeks) did; its authors conclude that creatine 'does not always lead to water retention'. Our pages had turned 'most' into 'all', added a claim about the skin that none of these papers makes, and left out the longer trials. They were written from the gist of the reviews, not checked against their sentences.
The paper
Burke R, et al. Nutrients 2023;15(9):2116. Pashayee-Khamene F, et al. J Int Soc Sports Nutr 2024;21(1):2380058. Antonio J, et al. J Int Soc Sports Nutr 2021;18:13.
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.

Newer day: September 28, 2026Older day: September 26, 2026The whole log

The full picture

How every claim on FitChef is checked, page by page.

We did the thinking. You just eat.

Get my week

It takes a minute.

ListenListen0:00Help