- What it said
- Six pages said the water creatine adds goes into the muscle cells and 'not under the skin' (on one Short, in its title), that it makes muscles look 'fuller, not bloated', and that it is temporary: 'a first-week event', with no lasting rise in total body water in training studies of 5 to 10 weeks. The study page for the 143-study meta-analysis said the water may be 'stored inside muscle cells'.
- What it says now
- The pages say that creatine raises total body water, that most of it is thought to sit inside cells and some outside them, and that in some short studies the water outside cells rose as well. Several training studies of 5 to 10 weeks found no rise in total body water, while a 28-day and an 8-week trial found one. None of the studies behind these pages measured puffiness.
- Why
- The papers say so. Burke et al. 2023: creatine 'increases total body water', and the majority of its hydrating effect is 'generally believed' to sit inside cells, which is not all of it. Pashayee-Khamene et al. 2024: part of the fat-free mass gain may be water retention '(both extra- and intracellular)', and more studies are needed to confirm it. Antonio et al. 2021: three days of creatine raised the water outside cells in one study; training studies of 5 to 10 weeks found no rise in total body water, but Powers et al. (28 days) and Ribeiro et al. (8 weeks) did; its authors conclude that creatine 'does not always lead to water retention'. Our pages had turned 'most' into 'all', added a claim about the skin that none of these papers makes, and left out the longer trials. They were written from the gist of the reviews, not checked against their sentences.
- Built on it
1 claim · 42 shorts
- The paper
- Burke R, et al. Nutrients 2023;15(9):2116. Pashayee-Khamene F, et al. J Int Soc Sports Nutr 2024;21(1):2380058. Antonio J, et al. J Int Soc Sports Nutr 2021;18:13.
- Found by
- Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.