FitChef

The log: one day.

September 29, 2026

10 corrections on 4 pages. Most arrive together: one paper read again against every page that cites it, and every page fixed the same day.

Refalo et al. 2025 3 corrections · 3 pages

September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong

A claim on women's muscle growth overstated what its two reviews found

What it said
The page called the 2025 review's 0.69% "less than one percentage point" and drew it as 99.31 percent overlap; presented the 2020 review as an independent second team that reached the same percentage-growth result "with perfect agreement"; said men's larger absolute gains were "entirely explained" by starting size; said women "recover faster between sessions" and could benefit from more frequent or higher-volume training; credited the paper with "the variable that matters is effort"; said the equal rate was "confirmed by 29 studies" and that they "confirmed there is one growth process"; counted 2,815 data points as "over 2,800 people"; called the review "the largest analysis ever conducted on this question"; gave the paper a title it does not have in the chart data; and rated the evidence with a bonus for two independent research teams.
What it says now
The 0.69% is shown as a relative difference, with a worked example, and the chart draws it as men ending about 0.69% larger from the same start. The 2020 review is described as sharing an author (Greg Nuckols) and as not separating raw from percentage gains. The absolute gap is "likely due to" starting size, as the authors write. The fatigue and recovery lines follow what each review says, and the program advice follows the paper's own conclusion: training may be prescribed similarly for both sexes, with the main differences driven by goals and preferences. The page says the studies did not test toning, counts measurements, drops the superlative and uses the paper's title. The bonus is removed and the claim's certainty is lowered; it is still rated High Certainty.
Why
The papers say otherwise. Refalo et al. 2025 (PeerJ) reports the 0.69% as a relative difference between men's and women's gains, not a gap in percentage points; it calls the absolute difference a "negligible to small effect" that is "likely due to" baseline muscle size, did not study toning, left load and effort out of its analyses, and concludes that training may be prescribed similarly for both sexes, with the main differences driven by goals and individual factors. Roberts, Nuckols & Krieger 2020 (J Strength Cond Res) found no significant sex difference in muscle growth, but its effect sizes did not separate absolute from relative change, and Greg Nuckols is an author of both reviews. The page had been written from our extraction notes, a brief on the 2020 review and a summary of a Stronger by Science article rather than from the papers' own wording, and our checks compared it with those notes. Both papers were checked against Mark's pastes on 2026-09-29.
The paper
Refalo MC, Nuckols G, Galpin AJ, Gallagher IJ, Hamilton DL, Fyfe JJ. Sex differences in absolute and relative changes in muscle size following resistance training in healthy adults: a systematic review with Bayesian meta-analysis. PeerJ. 2025;13:e19042Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.

September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong

A Short on genetics and muscle growth misstated two reviews of men’s and women’s gains

What it said
The page said a 29-study review of "over a thousand direct comparisons" found men and women differ by "less than one percentage point", so sex "explains less than 1%" of muscle growth differences, and that a second, independent review of 50 studies confirmed it with "every single study in agreement". It cited the 2025 review under a title the paper does not have.
What it says now
The page says that across 29 studies, gains relative to starting size were similar (from the same start, men would end about 0.69% larger), and that men’s absolute gains were slightly larger. It describes the 2020 review as sharing an author with the 2025 one, with 12 outcomes from 10 studies for muscle growth, and cites the 2025 review by its title.
Why
The papers say otherwise. Refalo et al. 2025 (PeerJ) pooled 68 outcomes from 29 studies and reports the 0.69% as a relative difference, not a share explained or a gap in percentage points. Roberts, Nuckols & Krieger 2020 (J Strength Cond Res) analysed 10 studies for muscle growth and reported low heterogeneity; Greg Nuckols is an author of both. The page was written from our notes on the reviews, not from their wording. Checked against Mark’s pastes, 2026-09-29.
The paper
Refalo MC, Nuckols G, Galpin AJ, Gallagher IJ, Hamilton DL, Fyfe JJ. Sex differences in absolute and relative changes in muscle size following resistance training in healthy adults: a systematic review with Bayesian meta-analysis. PeerJ. 2025;13:e19042Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.

September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong

A Short on first-year muscle gain misstated a review’s findings on men and women

What it said
The page said men and women build muscle at "virtually the same relative rate, separated by less than one percentage point", gave the review’s absolute result (SMD = 0.19) as that same gap, and said the frameworks that set different expectations by sex solve "a problem the data does not support". It cited the review under a title the paper does not have, in Sports Medicine.
What it says now
The page reports both results: relative to starting size, gains were similar (from the same start, men would end about 0.69% larger), and men’s absolute gains were slightly larger, a negligible to small effect the authors think is likely due to men’s larger starting muscle. It cites the review by its title, in PeerJ, with its DOI.
Why
The paper says otherwise. Refalo et al. 2025 (PeerJ) reports the 0.69% as a relative difference, not a gap in percentage points, and its SMD of 0.19 as a separate, absolute result favouring males. The page was written from our notes on the review, not from the paper’s wording. Checked against Mark’s paste, 2026-09-29.
The paper
Refalo MC, Nuckols G, Galpin AJ, Gallagher IJ, Hamilton DL, Fyfe JJ. Sex differences in absolute and relative changes in muscle size following resistance training in healthy adults: a systematic review with Bayesian meta-analysis. PeerJ. 2025;13:e19042Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.
A Short on first-year muscle gain said muscle growth stops at 12 to 20 weekly sets

September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong

What it said
The page's FAQ said muscle growth "plateaus around twelve to twenty sets per muscle group per week" and that beyond that "additional volume stops helping". It cited the 2025 volume meta-analysis under a slightly different title, without its DOI.
What it says now
The FAQ says what that meta-analysis found: muscle gains rose as weekly sets rose, with diminishing returns, which were considerably more pronounced for strength. The citation carries the published title and the DOI.
Why
The paper says otherwise. Pelland et al. 2025 (Sports Med) found that "gains in muscle size and strength increase as volume increases", with diminishing returns; the abstract describes no plateau for muscle growth. Checked against Mark's paste of the journal page (the abstract; the full text is paywalled), 2026-09-29.
The paper
Pelland JC, Remmert JF, Robinson ZP, Hinson SR, Zourdos MC. The Resistance Training Dose Response: Meta-Regressions Exploring the Effects of Weekly Volume and Frequency on Muscle Hypertrophy and Strength Gains. Sports Med. 2026;56:481-505Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.
A Short on first-year muscle gain read a range of group averages as individual results

September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong

What it said
The page said a meta-analysis of resistance training found individual results "ranging from zero to nearly sixteen pounds", and that "the best responder in ten weeks gained more muscle than the twenty-five-pound prediction assigns to an entire year". It called the review "the largest", and said no study has measured a full year of training, so the first-year prediction "has never been directly tested"; its search title read "Predicted, Never Measured".
What it says now
The page says the zero-to-sixteen-pound range is the spread of the study groups' average gains, not of individuals, and no longer claims a best responder. It calls the review what its authors did in 2020, the largest to date, and says its programs averaged about ten weeks. It notes that the highest group average came from a study of growth-hormone treatment. It no longer says a year of training has never been measured.
Why
The paper says otherwise. Benito et al. 2020 (Int J Environ Res Public Health) reports a range of heterogeneity from 0 to 7.2 kg; its Table 1 shows these are study-group means, and 7.2 kg (about 16 lb) is less than 20 to 25 lb. The review does not claim no year-long study exists, and trials of resistance training lasting up to 52 weeks are in another meta-analysis the page cites. The page was written from our notes on the review. Checked against Mark's pastes, 2026-09-29.
The paper
Benito PJ, Cupeiro R, Ramos-Campo DJ, Alcaraz PE, Rubio-Arias JÁ. A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis of the Effect of Resistance Training on Whole-Body Muscle Growth in Healthy Adult Males. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020;17(4):1285Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.
A Short on first-year muscle gain credited a protein meta-analysis with a figure it does not give

September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong

What it said
The page said effort in the gym "accounts for ninety-one percent of the muscle-building stimulus", and that training "explained 91 ± 5.6% of variance" in lean-mass gains, with protein supplements the rest. Its FAQ said protein's benefit "increases as you get more experienced".
What it says now
The page gives the paper's own numbers: training alone added about 1.1 kg (2.4 lb) of lean mass over programs averaging 13 weeks, and protein supplements added about 0.3 kg on top; the added effect was smaller, and not statistically significant, in untrained participants and larger in resistance-trained ones. The authors call training alone "the much more potent stimulus".
Why
The paper says otherwise. Morton et al. 2018 (Br J Sports Med) gives no 91% or ± 5.6% figure; its 9% is the part of the 1RM strength gain that protein added, not a share of muscle growth. The page was written from our notes on the paper, and our checks compared it with those notes. Checked against Mark's paste of the paper, 2026-09-29.
The paper
Morton RW, Murphy KT, McKellar SR, et al. A systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression of the effect of protein supplementation on resistance training-induced gains in muscle mass and strength in healthy adults. Br J Sports Med. 2018;52(6):376-384Read the paper
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.
Hubal et al. 2005 2 corrections · 2 pages

September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong

A Short on genetics and muscle growth misread its main study and named a cause it never tested

What it said
The page was titled "The 30-Fold Gap in Muscle Growth Nobody Can Explain". It said that on the same 12-week program, muscle growth ranged from 2% to 59%, that every participant gained at least some muscle ("Nobody got zero"), and that genetics create that range. It said testosterone, age and effort explain almost none of it, gave two correlations as positive, and said all 585 trained in the "same gym".
What it says now
The page gives the study’s range as it is: from a 2% loss to a 59% gain in biceps size, with some people showing little to no gain, and no fold ratio. It says the paper reports no genetic result, so it cannot say how much genetics limit anyone, and reports what was tested: men and women were spread out about equally, and neither age nor training volume predicted who gained most. The study ran at eight sites.
Why
The paper says otherwise. Hubal et al. 2005 (Med Sci Sports Exerc) reports size changes of −2 to +59%, with "some subjects showing little to no gain", and correlations of −0.09 for age and for women’s training volume. It reports no genetic result and no testosterone levels. In the PDF’s text layer its minus signs are invisible characters, so the range read "2 to 59%"; the page was built from that reading, and our checks compared it with our notes rather than with the journal’s abstract. Checked against Mark’s pastes of the full text and the journal’s abstract page.
The paper
Hubal MJ, Gordish-Dressman H, Thompson PD, et al. Variability in Muscle Size and Strength Gain after Unilateral Resistance Training. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2005;37(6):964-972
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.

September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong

A Short on first-year muscle gain misread one study’s range of results

What it said
The page said that when 585 people did the same arm-training program, muscle growth ranged from 2% to 59%, "a thirty-fold gap" between the lowest and highest responder, which it called "likely polygenic". It said all 585 trained in the "same gym", and credited the study to the Journal of Applied Physiology.
What it says now
The page gives the study’s range as it is: from a 2% loss to a 59% gain in biceps size, with some people showing little to no gain. It no longer gives a fold ratio or a genetic cause: the study did not find what explains the spread, and neither age nor training volume predicted it. The study ran at eight sites, and it is credited to Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise.
Why
The paper says otherwise. Hubal et al. 2005 (Med Sci Sports Exerc) reports size changes of −2 to +59%: the lowest responders lost biceps size, so no fold ratio can be taken, and the paper names no genetic cause. In the PDF’s text layer its minus signs are invisible characters, so the range read "2 to 59%"; the page was written from that reading, and our checks compared it with our notes rather than with the journal’s abstract. Checked against Mark’s pastes of the full text and the journal’s abstract page.
The paper
Hubal MJ, Gordish-Dressman H, Thompson PD, et al. Variability in Muscle Size and Strength Gain after Unilateral Resistance Training. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2005;37(6):964-972
Found by
Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.
Guo et al. 2023 2 corrections · 1 page

September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong

A study page gave the wrong number of studies behind a review's age and interval subgroups

What it said
The page said the age and interval subgroup findings rested on "only four to seven studies per subgroup".
What it says now
The page gives the review's own counts: 1 to 7 studies in the middle-aged subgroups (waist 1, body fat percentage 4, fitness 7) and 9 to 15 in the interval subgroups for body fat percentage and fitness (9 and 11, 15 and 12), with HIIT compared only with moderate cardio within each subgroup.
Why
Table 4 of the review lists 1, 4 and 7 studies in the 45-60-year waist, body-fat and VO2peak subgroups, and 9, 11, 15 and 12 studies in the interval subgroups for body fat percentage and VO2peak. Our page plan gave "4-7 studies per subgroup" for both kinds of subgroup, and the text was not checked against Table 4. The fix was checked word for word against the paper and by an independent reviewer before it was applied.
The paper
Guo Z, Li M, Cai J, Gong W, Liu Y, Liu Z. Effect of High-Intensity Interval Training vs. Moderate-Intensity Continuous Training on Fat Loss and Cardiorespiratory Fitness in the Young and Middle-Aged a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2023;20(6):4741.Read the paper
Found by
Our own checks of the site.

September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong

A study page read a review's HIIT interval subgroups as a verdict that shorter intervals suit fitness and longer ones fat loss; the review reports no test between them

What it said
The page said that in this review shorter intervals (one to three minutes) were better for cardiovascular fitness while longer intervals (three minutes or more) were better for the small fat-loss advantage, called it a paradox, and advised that "if you are doing HIIT for heart health, shorter bursts with more recovery appear to work better."
What it says now
The page says the review split its trials by "interval protocol" (under 3 minutes, or 3 minutes or more) without saying what those minutes measure, compared HIIT only with moderate cardio within each group, and reports no test of one group against the other; it quotes the authors' own hedge that each group "seemed to" do more on one outcome. So the review does not show that either interval length is better for either goal. The heart-health advice is gone.
Why
The review's subgroup analysis "was only performed on the between-group effect (HIIT vs. MICT)", it reports no test between its two interval groups, and where its discussion sets the two side by side it says that HIIT of 3-minute-plus intervals "seemed to cause more reduction" in body fat percentage while HIIT of 1 to 3 minutes "seemed to promote" VO2peak more. The paper never says what its interval minutes measure, and no line of it links shorter bursts or longer recovery to heart health. Our extraction notes recorded the two subgroup results as one interval length beating the other, in a quote stitched from two sentences of the paper; the page was written from those notes, and the heart-health sentence was added in the writing. The fix was checked word for word against the paper and by an independent reviewer before it was applied.
The paper
Guo Z, Li M, Cai J, Gong W, Liu Y, Liu Z. Effect of High-Intensity Interval Training vs. Moderate-Intensity Continuous Training on Fat Loss and Cardiorespiratory Fitness in the Young and Middle-Aged a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2023;20(6):4741.Read the paper
Found by
Our own checks of the site.

Newer day: September 30, 2026Older day: September 28, 2026The whole log

The full picture

How every claim on FitChef is checked, page by page.

We did the thinking. You just eat.

Get my week

It takes a minute.

ListenListen0:00Help