September 29, 2026 · We got it wrong
A claim on women's muscle growth overstated what its two reviews found
- What it said
- The page called the 2025 review's 0.69% "less than one percentage point" and drew it as 99.31 percent overlap; presented the 2020 review as an independent second team that reached the same percentage-growth result "with perfect agreement"; said men's larger absolute gains were "entirely explained" by starting size; said women "recover faster between sessions" and could benefit from more frequent or higher-volume training; credited the paper with "the variable that matters is effort"; said the equal rate was "confirmed by 29 studies" and that they "confirmed there is one growth process"; counted 2,815 data points as "over 2,800 people"; called the review "the largest analysis ever conducted on this question"; gave the paper a title it does not have in the chart data; and rated the evidence with a bonus for two independent research teams.
- What it says now
- The 0.69% is shown as a relative difference, with a worked example, and the chart draws it as men ending about 0.69% larger from the same start. The 2020 review is described as sharing an author (Greg Nuckols) and as not separating raw from percentage gains. The absolute gap is "likely due to" starting size, as the authors write. The fatigue and recovery lines follow what each review says, and the program advice follows the paper's own conclusion: training may be prescribed similarly for both sexes, with the main differences driven by goals and preferences. The page says the studies did not test toning, counts measurements, drops the superlative and uses the paper's title. The bonus is removed and the claim's certainty is lowered; it is still rated High Certainty.
- Why
- The papers say otherwise. Refalo et al. 2025 (PeerJ) reports the 0.69% as a relative difference between men's and women's gains, not a gap in percentage points; it calls the absolute difference a "negligible to small effect" that is "likely due to" baseline muscle size, did not study toning, left load and effort out of its analyses, and concludes that training may be prescribed similarly for both sexes, with the main differences driven by goals and individual factors. Roberts, Nuckols & Krieger 2020 (J Strength Cond Res) found no significant sex difference in muscle growth, but its effect sizes did not separate absolute from relative change, and Greg Nuckols is an author of both reviews. The page had been written from our extraction notes, a brief on the 2020 review and a summary of a Stronger by Science article rather than from the papers' own wording, and our checks compared it with those notes. Both papers were checked against Mark's pastes on 2026-09-29.
- Built on it
1 guide · 24 shorts
- The paper
- Refalo MC, Nuckols G, Galpin AJ, Gallagher IJ, Hamilton DL, Fyfe JJ. Sex differences in absolute and relative changes in muscle size following resistance training in healthy adults: a systematic review with Bayesian meta-analysis. PeerJ. 2025;13:e19042Read the paper
- Found by
- Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.