October 2, 2026 · We got it wrong
- What it said
- The page said the paper never tested the online coaching app against the PDF plan on strength, so "almost identical" was only a comparison of averages. It said so in the story, the first Fast Takeaway, the audio and the summary written for AI tools, which also gave that comparison's effect size as "Not reported".
- What it says now
- The page says "almost identical" is a plain comparison of the two groups' averages: squat up 19.2 kg against 19.4 kg, bench press up 8.2 kg against 7.7 kg. The summary for AI tools adds that, for the squat, the paper's text reports no app-against-PDF result; for the bench press it found no significant group effect; and its Figure 2 gives mean differences for pairwise comparisons.
- Why
- The paper follows significant effects with Bonferroni-corrected tests between groups, and its Figure 2 caption says mean differences and standardized mean differences are provided for pairwise comparisons. Its text reports the coached group against each format for the squat, and no significant interaction or group effect for the bench press. It never says the app and the PDF were not compared. Our writer read the absence of an app-against-PDF line in the text as "never tested".
- Corrected
- Built on it
2 claims · 1 guide · 3 shorts
- The paper
- Gavanda S, Held S, Schrey S, Oberwetter K, Lazzaro P-GM, Pergelt M, Geisler S. Optimizing Resistance Training Outcomes: Comparing In-Person Supervision, Online Coaching, and Self-Guided Approaches: A Randomized Controlled Trial. J Strength Cond Res. 2025;39(11):1129-1137.Read the paper
- Found by
- Our own reading of the whole page against its paper.